Leaving Thumbtack in New York?
Your Thumbtack Pay-per-contact — you pay to message even if homeowner never replies. setup is probably costing you $8,040/year in lead fees and subscriptions for 48 closed jobs at New York's median project values. AskBaily's 12% take-rate on the same volume runs roughly $489,600/year — a $-481,560 annual delta. Here's how $NY DOS + NYC DOB/DCWP-licensed New York contractors are migrating.
New York licensing fit
AskBaily verifies your NY Department of State (HIC outside NYC) + NYC Department of Buildings + DCWP (inside NYC) credentials live at match-time — not from a self-reported signup form from six months ago. NYC splits licensing across DOB (trades) and DCWP (HIC for GC-equivalent) — AskBaily verifies both and surfaces Local Law 97 implications on every condo/co-op scope.Our matching engine understands this and won't surface a scope outside your license class.
Primary New York metro coverage: NYC, Buffalo, Rochester. Smaller metros have narrower partner pools but still route homeowners to 1 verified match per job.
The 5-step migration
1. Apply at /for-pros/recruit/new-york
3-minute application. We verify your NY DOS + NYC DOB/DCWP license class, bond, and insurance live against NY Department of State (HIC outside NYC) + NYC Department of Buildings + DCWP (inside NYC). No credit check, no subscription fee at signup.
2. Export your Thumbtack lead history (last 90 days)
From your Thumbtack pro dashboard, export lead history including trade, project size, and close rate. We use this to calibrate match density and understand your service mix.
3. Run a 30-90 day pilot — both platforms active
Keep your Thumbtack subscription running. Start accepting AskBaily matches in parallel. Compare actual close rates, actual unit economics, and actual homeowner quality side-by-side.
4. Audit with /tools/lead-spend-audit
Paste your Thumbtack monthly spend into the tool. Get the true per-closed-customer CAC vs AskBaily's 12% take-rate on closes. Shareable URL you can send to your accountant.
5. File Thumbtack cancellation notice and migrate full-time
No long-term contract — but credits expire in 12 months.. File written notice per your contract, finish out any remaining paid-for leads, and migrate 100% to AskBaily. Most New York migrations close within 60 days.
Frequently asked questions
How much does Thumbtack actually cost New York contractors per year?
On a median New York kitchen remodel (~$85,000) a contractor closing 4 jobs per month from Thumbtack leads pays roughly $8,040 per year in lead fees + subscriptions. That's a true per-closed-customer CAC of $168. Our /tools/lead-spend-audit runs the math against your actual invoice.
Does AskBaily work with NY DOS + NYC DOB/DCWP-licensed New York contractors?
Yes — we verify NY Department of State (HIC outside NYC) + NYC Department of Buildings + DCWP (inside NYC) license class live at the moment of match. Every New York partner in our network is NY DOS + NYC DOB/DCWP-active, bonded per state statute, and insurance-verified via ACORD 25 re-check. NYC splits licensing across DOB (trades) and DCWP (HIC for GC-equivalent) — AskBaily verifies both and surfaces Local Law 97 implications on every condo/co-op scope.
What's the annual cost difference between Thumbtack and AskBaily in New York?
Apples-to-apples, 4 closes/month on median New York projects: Thumbtack = ~$8,040/year (lead fees + no subscription). AskBaily = ~$489,600/year (12% take-rate on closes only, no lead fees). Net delta: $-481,560/year. Your actual math varies by close rate and project mix.
Can I run AskBaily in parallel with Thumbtack before cancelling?
Yes. Recommended 30-90 day pilot. Keep your Thumbtack subscription active, apply to AskBaily at /for-pros/recruit/new-york, and compare unit economics. Most New York contractors decide within 60 days. AskBaily requires no subscription or lock-in — just 30 days notice in writing if you want to leave.
Which New York metros does AskBaily cover?
Primary match density in NYC, Buffalo, Rochester. We have active partners in every NY zip that passes NY DOS + NYC DOB/DCWP verification, but partner depth varies — the top metros have 5-15+ verified GCs per service category, smaller metros have 1-3. /for-pros/recruit/new-york lists the current New York partner count.
What happens to my Thumbtack reviews if I migrate?
Reviews left on Thumbtack stay on Thumbtack — we cannot export them. Contractors migrating typically ask past clients (the ones whose phone numbers they kept) to leave a review on AskBaily after a new project closes. This builds an AskBaily-owned review set rather than borrowing reputation from a platform you're leaving.
How is AskBaily different from just another Pay-per-contact — you pay to message even if homeowner never replies. platform?
AskBaily charges zero lead fees. Zero contact fees. Zero subscriptions. We earn a tiered take-rate (8-15%) only when you close a job — lower tier for higher volume. Read our full fee schedule on /transparency. Our /why-not-shared-leads page explains why the shared-lead model structurally can't align platform + contractor + homeowner incentives, and why exclusive-match is the only fix.
What's the Thumbtack, Inc. cancellation process?
No long-term contract — but credits expire in 12 months.. Check your Thumbtack agreement for the specific notice window and auto-renewal date. We recommend running AskBaily in parallel during notice to avoid a coverage gap on leads you're already paying for.